Skip to main content

Book Review: Sorry! I Loved You

"Sorry! I Loved You" is the debut work of Mr. Saksham Mittal. First of all, I shall like to congratulate him for picking up a pen and daring to write a book. Writing is a noble profession and not everyone's cup of tea. As of late, Indian literary society is witnessing a surge in the number of potential debutantes and this is partially has to do with increasing internet penetration in country. Then there are companies like Amazon and many new age publishers who are giving a platform to all the aspiring writers. So almost everyone is writing nowadays and they are getting published too. They are even getting promoted very heavily and although I don't know what they need to do to bag the tag of a 'bestselling book', they still manage to stir the plot quite a bit. There is a great side-effect to this phenomenon too. Since almost all of them are writing, the most of them 'almost' are coming up with meaningless, soulless and despicable matter-in-hand. Unfortunately, Mr. Mittal doesn't do anything anything to turn the tide in his favor and whatever matter is in there in his book (I only read 24 pages, that too with great difficulty), his publisher too hasn't helped him in that regard. You can read the blurb or even a summary of it anywhere on any book-selling portal so I wouldn't waste my time elaborating on them but I would like to do the same for pointing the mistakes that plague this book.

A story will be a story. Judging it might be subjective. For someone, it might be good; for another, not so good, even loathsome. So I wouldn't critic the story part of it but since anyone can ask me that how can I judge a book by only going through 24 pages of it, I would like to justify my take on that matter. You see, reviewing the literature is quite similar to reviewing a movie. So when one goes to watch a movie and finds out that lead actors are limping badly with their dialogue-delivery and cannot act according to the situation despite the 'promising plot',you need not be an Einstein to think that this movie is going to bomb on box office. Similarly, here in this book, I found the basic premise completely at fault. Till page 24, I found enough grammatical mistakes to decide not to move any further with it. Take for example: 'My eyes didn't WANTED to move'. This is a fundamental problem. Using the second form of verb in a negative sentence of Past Indefinite Tense is completely unacceptable to me and then on page 16, once is spelled as 'onve'. Another miss: 'She DANCE so well' on page 18. I am not going to illustrate what else are there on pages 17, 23 and 24. Prepositions are missing. Sentence formation goes out for a toss. Quality of pages and printing, another deterrent and thus I literally found out myself in a dilemma whether I should blame the author of this book for all these mishaps or its publisher and proofreaders. You must have understood, hopefully, by now that 'correct language and grammar' are the basic ingredients of a book and even if you are not a 'notorious Grammar Nazi', you are bound to cringe over these mistakes. In this way, I cannot coerce myself into giving this book more than one mark out of five. That 'one mark' shall mark the efforts Mr. Saksham has put up with in coming up with this book.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

P.S. Hoffman & Joaquin Phoenix: The Master

My infatuation with the movies is well known but my involvement with the actors and their characters is even more heartwarming. There are innumerable movies that I saw simply because they featured my favorite actors, however they themselves were not great. Examples could be infinite, however for the sake of this article I'll have to produce something here. Anger Management for Jack Nicholson (boy, isn't he a legend?), Swing Vote for Kevin Costner, Snatch for Brad Pitt, Legends of the Fall (Brad Pitt), Leon: The Professional, Immortal Beloved, Bram Stroker's Dracula, State of Grace & Prick up your ears; all for Gary Oldman (mind you, he is a chameleon). Meanwhile, I started accumulating some of the finest performances by some of the legendary actors of all time. Very recently, as anyone who follows me regularly knows, I grew very much fond of the craft and artistry of Daniel Day-Lewis. He is a fine, fine actor whose study and impersonation of a character is often pictur...

BBC's India's Daughter: An Indian Response

I assume you all have watched BBC's Documentary on Nirbhaya a.k.a Jyoti Singh (I don't know whether I'm legally entitled to speak up her name publicly in India or not, but let's take the risk). It goes by the name 'India's Daughter' in India, but at the same time, it's banned here. Though it was released way back on 4th March and I downloaded it right away on the very next day for my relatives but only yesterday, I got to watch it and that's only because Meryl Streep vouched for it for an elusive 'Oscars Nomination'. That's not to say that I was skeptical of its content or plot but somewhere I was afraid that I couldn't quite grasp its central idea. So let me tell you that if you are a parent or a certain male chauvinist, you can certainly do away with a strong stomach for it will certainly test your strength of character. Awaneendra who was accompanying Jyoti that fateful night, was when asked later to comment on this documentary, ...

Film Essay: Room (2015)

This is an appreciation post for Oscars Best Feature Film Nominee, the number 7th, Room (2016). Every once in a while in English-speaking world, a courageous director comes up with an audacious project that blows your mind away and you just couldn't fathom what you really experienced. These words might sound hollow if I am going to describe the authenticity of Room (2015). Whatever I shall be writing hereafter shall in no way do justice to the brilliance of this movie and I cannot possibly come up with any more adjectives to ornament it for they all would fall short. So let me narrate you the experiences of my fellow colleagues who are more popular, widely read and certainly more accomplished than me: Rotten Tomatoes: Led by incredible work from Brie Larson and Jacob Tremblay, Room makes for an unforgettably harrowing – and undeniably rewarding – experience. Richard Roeper (Chicago Sun-Times) : The most impressive piece of filmmaking I've seen in 2015, and one of the best...